Erik and I flew up to New York late on Friday, May 10th. After arriving in Manhattan well past midnight, we headed to my family’s apartment on the Upper East side and did the quintessential New Yorker thing….ordered Chinese food delivery.
We/(I) slept in the next morning until about 10:00 a.m. (I later found out that while I thought Erik was also sleeping, he had been up since 6 a.m. putting the final touches on my big surprise!) After I woke up, Erik suggested that we go to our favorite breakfast spot – Sarabeth’s in Central Park. Nothing fishy here – we always eat at Sarabeth’s, however when Erik put on his favorite navy suit, I just knew something was up. I asked him what he wanted me to wear, and he picked out my fancy gold dress – at this point I had a fit because who wears a suit and dress to breakfast?! I begged him to leave his jacket at home, but he insisted on bringing it – – and refused to put it on…hmmm…
In my head I knew something was up, but didn’t think that it would actually be happening on Saturday morning, so I just went along. I developed this crazy plan in my head that all the people in Sarabeth’s would think that we were going to a wedding later in the day, thus why we were dressed so fancy!
After breakfast at Sarabeth’s, Erik told me that we were going to see an art exhibit at The Plaza Hotel around the corner. He FINALLY put his suit jacket on, and I kept my cool as we took the short walk from Sarabeth’s over to The Plaza. Once we walked in, Erik shook hands and basically hugged the extremely overly excited maitre d’ and he then walked us upstairs to the Rose Room which overlooks the Champagne Lounge.
As soon as we sat down (I didn’t even have time to take off my jacket!), Erik started talking. I stopped him and said “WAIT! Shouldn’t we order a drink first?!” He was shocked and looked around and then I said “OK, never mind – keep going, keep going!” After a beautiful speech about how much he loves me and wants to spend the rest of his life with me, Erik got down on one knee and asked! “YES! Of Course!” I said!
In true Erik fashion, he thought of absolutely everything – and had both our parents waiting nearby and a photographer (also his long time good friend, Cary) capturing every single moment.
Congrats Amanda and Erik! Thanks for sharing your love story with us.
To share your Proposal story, please email firstname.lastname@example.org with the subject ‘AP Proposal’. If you would just like to share a picture of your engagement ring as part of our #APbling feature on Instagram, please use the subject ‘AP Bling’ in your email.